I had never thought of his condition as a reason we couldn’t enjoy important moments together.
He was the same person who had made that promise with me when we were six.
And now he had arrived to keep it.
I couldn’t imagine telling him that he had come all this way only to be turned away.
For a moment, I was afraid my mother was going to stop us from going.
But I had completely misunderstood her.
She wasn’t trying to tell me that Tobias wasn’t good enough to be my prom date.
She wanted me to know something about him.
Something that had happened twelve years earlier.
Something I had never been told.
My mother began explaining that when Tobias and I were six years old, something important had taken place.
It had happened during one of the most difficult periods of her life.
A time she still remembered as her darkest year.
And somehow, Tobias had been part of what happened.
As I listened, I realized there was a side of our childhood friendship I had never known about.
My mother had kept this story from me for twelve years.
It involved Tobias, the difficult time she had gone through, and a promise I hadn’t even known existed.
I had always believed that the most important promise Tobias and I had made was the one about going to prom together.
But now I was discovering that there had been another promise.
One connected to my mother.
One that had remained a secret throughout my childhood.
I couldn’t understand why she had waited so long to tell me.
And I couldn’t imagine what Tobias, at only six years old, could have done that still meant so much to her twelve years later.
Suddenly, the evening felt different.
Tobias was downstairs in his navy suit, holding flowers and waiting to take me to prom.
Meanwhile, I was upstairs learning that our friendship had a history far deeper than I had ever realized.
I had thought I knew everything important about my best friend.
After all, we had known each other since we were little.
But my mother’s revelation made me question how much of our shared past I truly understood.
And just when I believed I was beginning to make sense of what she had told me, I learned there was still something else.
Tobias had been keeping a secret of his own.
A secret I knew nothing about.
And before that unforgettable prom night was over, I would discover that the promise we made at six years old was only one part of a much bigger story.
PART 2: A Promise Between Two Six-Year-Olds
Tobias Miller and I became friends during our first week of elementary school in Columbus, Ohio.
We had two things in common. Neither of us liked raisins, and we both believed dinosaurs were the most interesting creatures that had ever existed.
Tobias had Down syndrome, but that was never what defined our friendship.
He was funny, stubborn, remarkably good at remembering baseball statistics, and completely incapable of pretending to like something just to make another person happy.
Once, when I proudly showed him a drawing of a dinosaur, he studied it carefully before announcing, “Tessa, that looks like a potato wearing a dinosaur costume.”
I refused to speak to him for ten minutes.
He spent those ten minutes laughing.
That was Tobias.
One afternoon, our teacher announced that she was getting married. Naturally, the entire class became fascinated with weddings.
Tobias declared that his wedding would have chocolate cake, baseball decorations, and absolutely no boring music.
Another boy laughed at him.
“Who would ever marry you?”
Tobias’s smile disappeared.
PART 3: The Darkest Year and the Locked Door
I still remember the afternoon that boy laughed at Tobias in the first grade.
See more on the next page