“Yes.”
He took another bite.
“That’s commitment.”
And in a way, he was right.
Time was part of the recipe.
A private chef could know techniques I didn’t. Someone else could plate food more beautifully.
But I knew Carol liked the browned corner of the potatoes.
I knew Ruth preferred dark meat.
I knew Beverly would take cranberry sauce even though she always claimed she didn’t want much.
I knew why the star-shaped shortbread cutter stayed in the second drawer beside the stove.
Daniel had given it to me when he was seven.
He’d picked it himself from a kitchen store with money he’d saved.
The cutter had cost almost nothing.
He’d handed it to me in a paper bag and watched me open it with such serious pride that I had treated it like silver ever since.
I still used it thirty-four years later.
Carol had seconds of the scalloped potatoes.
“I have tried to make these for twenty years.”
“You use too much cheese.”
Her mouth dropped open.
“You told me there was no such thing.”
“There is when you’re trying to taste the potatoes.”
“Traitor.”
“And nutmeg.”
“What?”
“That’s what you’re missing.”
She grabbed a paper napkin.
“How much?”
“Not enough to taste.”
“That is not a measurement.”
“It is in my mother’s kitchen.”
She wrote NUTMEG in large letters anyway.
Dolores ate two Pfeffernüsse cookies after dinner.
Then she picked up a third and studied it.
“My mother made these.”
Her voice had changed.
“She was from Stuttgart.”
“I know.”
“Before the war, she made them every Christmas.”
Dolores turned the cookie over.
“These taste right.”
No one said anything for a moment.
Then she took a bite.
That was all.
After dinner, we moved into the living room.
Nobody seemed eager to leave the table, so coffee appeared first.
Then plates of cookies followed us.
Ruth put on another record.
Dolores told stories about Germany.
Jerome talked about Atlanta and his grandmother’s red velvet cake.
“She made one every Sunday,” he said.
“Every Sunday?” Marcus asked.
“Every Sunday.”
“Why?”
“Because she believed store-bought cake was a moral failure.”
Beverly nearly spilled her coffee laughing.
“My grandmother felt that way about cornbread.”
Marcus said his family believed no guest should ever be allowed to leave while food remained on the table.
Priya told us again about her grandmother’s lamb with twenty-two mysterious spices.
Carol held the napkin with NUTMEG written on it and said, “At least Gwendolyn writes something down.”
I sat in the chair near the window.
From there, I could see the tree.
Daniel’s kindergarten picture.
His clay handprint.
My mother’s recipe box sat on the kitchen counter beyond the doorway.
For the first time all season, the old things in my house didn’t feel old.
They felt used.
Passed along.
Still useful.
At 4:15, my phone rang.
Daniel.
For a second, I considered letting it go to voicemail.
Not to punish him.
The room was simply full, and for once I did not feel that familiar pull to stop everything the second my son called.
Then I answered.
I stepped onto the back porch so I could hear.
The cold air hit my face.
The sun was low, turning the edge of the yard orange.
“Hi, sweetheart.”
“Mom.”
His voice sounded different.
Tired.
Maybe embarrassed.
“How’s your Christmas?”
“Wonderful.”
I didn’t say it brightly to prove anything.
I meant it.
There was a pause.
“That’s good.”
“How is Asheville?”
“The house is beautiful.”
“I’m glad.”
“The view is ridiculous. You can see mountains from almost every room.”
“That sounds lovely.”
Another pause.
Then Daniel cleared his throat.
“Natalie’s dad didn’t like the chef’s menu.”
“Oh?”
“He thought it was too experimental.”
“That’s unfortunate.”
“Then Richard made some comment about the wine, and Natalie’s dad got annoyed, and there was this whole thing during dinner.”
I leaned against the porch railing.
Daniel continued.
“The food was good. Really good.”
“But?”
He sighed.
“I don’t know.”
I waited.
“It doesn’t feel like Christmas.”
His voice dropped.
“I keep thinking about your chicken.”
I looked through the kitchen window.
Jerome was standing at the counter eating something off a plate.
Probably more chicken.
“There will be leftovers.”
“You think?”
“I cooked for seventeen people as if I expected thirty.”
He laughed softly.
For the first time all day, I heard the boy in his voice.
“Did everybody come?”
“Every single one.”
“Seventeen people.”
“Seventeen.”
“What did you make?”
I told him.
Chicken.
Ham.
Potatoes.
Corn pudding.
Cranberry sauce.
Cookies.
When I mentioned the Pfeffernüsse, he groaned.
“Mom.”
“What?”
“You made those too?”
“Of course.”
“Do you have any left?”
“I hid a tin.”
“From seventeen people?”
“From Ruth.”
He laughed again.
Then he went quiet.
“I’m sorry.”
I didn’t rush to fill the silence.
Finally he said, “What I said about your cooking was awful.”
“It hurt.”
“I know.”
“I don’t think you did know when you said it.”
“No.”
Another pause.
“I thought I was trying to keep Natalie happy.”
“I understand that.”
“But I made you sound like something I needed to apologize for.”
That was closer to the truth than anything I could have said for him.
“Yes,” I said.
“I’m sorry.”
This time I believed he understood the sentence he was saying.
I looked across the yard at the last strip of orange light.
“You can come by tomorrow if you want.”
“Really?”
“We’ll have leftovers for lunch.”
“Chicken?”
“If Jerome hasn’t finished it.”
Daniel laughed.
“Mom?”
“Yes?”
“Merry Christmas.”
“Merry Christmas, Daniel.”
I went back inside.
Nobody asked what the call had been about.
Ruth glanced at me from across the room.
I nodded once.
She nodded back.
Then Beverly called out, “Gwendolyn, settle something. Is canned cranberry sauce acceptable under any circumstances?”
“Absolutely.”
Beverly looked triumphant.
Ruth shouted, “Coward.”
The room erupted again.
We stayed together until well after dark.
People packed leftovers into containers.
Marcus took potatoes.
Beverly took ham.
Jerome left with enough chicken for two meals, despite insisting he didn’t need it.
Dolores took Pfeffernüsse wrapped carefully in foil.
At the front door, Carol removed the little silver bell from my tree and held it in her palm.
“I think I’m ready to put it on my own tree.”
“I’m glad.”
She hugged me.
After the last guest left, Ruth stayed.
The house looked exactly like a house should look after a good Christmas.
Glasses everywhere.
Cookie crumbs on the coffee table.
A napkin under the couch.
Serving spoons in the wrong dishes.
Half-burned candles.
Stacks of plates in the kitchen.
“You happy?” Ruth asked.
I considered the question.
“Yes.”
“Good.”
She put on her coat.
At the door, she pointed at me.
“Do not clean all of this tonight.”
“I wasn’t planning to.”
“You’re lying.”
“I’ll only do the kitchen.”
“Gwendolyn.”
“Go home, Ruth.”
She laughed and left.
The next morning, Daniel arrived just before noon.
Alone.
“Natalie stayed in Asheville?”
“She went out with her mother. I’m driving back later.”
He took off his coat.
For a second, we stood in the front hallway looking at each other.
Then he noticed the dining room.
The extra table was still there.
Several chairs had been pushed back at odd angles.
A forgotten wineglass sat near the far end.
“Wow.”
“What?”
“It looks like something actually happened here.”
“Something did.”
He walked into the living room.
He stopped at the tree.
Then he noticed the photograph on my phone lying on the side table.
Priya had taken it the previous afternoon and sent it to me before bed.
All seventeen of us were around the table.
Dolores was raising her glass.
Jerome was laughing.
Ruth had apparently been talking when the picture was taken because her mouth was open.
I was standing near the center holding a platter.
Daniel picked up the phone.
“That’s Jerome?”
“Yes.”
“The student from your literacy program?”
“Yes.”
“And that’s Priya?”
I nodded.
He studied the picture.
“You really had seventeen people.”
“You’ve said that four times now.”
“I know.”
He set the phone down.
“I don’t know what I expected.”
I did.
But I let him say it.
He looked around the room.
“I guess I thought you’d be here alone.”
“Why?”
His face changed.
“I don’t know.”
“Daniel.”
He sat on the couch.
“I think I assumed you were waiting for us.”
I sat in the chair across from him.
“For Christmas?”
“For everything, maybe.”
Neither of us spoke for a few seconds.
“I think I’ve always assumed you’d be here,” he said. “Same house. Same dinner. Same Christmas.”
He rubbed his hands together.
“Like I could come when I wanted and skip it when I wanted, and it would all still be waiting.”
“For a long time, it was.”
He nodded.
“I know.”
I went into the kitchen and reheated leftovers.
Chicken.
Potatoes.
Green beans.
A little ham.
I put two Pfeffernüsse on each plate even though cookies had no business being served with lunch.
When I set the chicken in front of him, Daniel took one bite and closed his eyes.
“That’s it.”
“What?”
“Christmas.”
I laughed.
“Don’t be ridiculous.”
“I’m serious.”
“Daniel, you are forty-one years old. Christmas is not poultry.”
“No.”
He took another bite.
“But this helps.”
For a while we ate without talking.
It was comfortable in a way the coffee-and-gifts visit had not been.
Finally he said, “I shouldn’t have put all of that on Natalie.”
I looked at him.
He continued.
“She wanted the Asheville trip to feel polished. She was nervous about her father and the people from work. But she didn’t make me call you and say what I said.”
“No.”
“I did that.”
I appreciated that he didn’t hide behind his wife.
“It was easier to say, ‘You know how Natalie is,’ than admit I was trying to impress people too.”
I took a drink of water.
“Probably.”
He gave me a faint smile.
“You’re not going to make this easy for me, are you?”
“I spent twenty-nine years teaching fourth grade. Natural consequences are important.”
That made him laugh.
Then I did too.
There was still hurt between us.
An apology did not erase the phone call.
But I didn’t need it erased.
I needed him to understand it.
Daniel finished his chicken.
He asked for more potatoes.
Before leaving, he walked into the kitchen and opened the second drawer.
He moved two utensils aside.
Then he found the metal star cutter.
“You still have this.”
“Of course I do.”
“I bought this at that kitchen store in the mall.”
“I remember.”
See more on the next page
