“We question whether the historically recognized boundary may differ from the deed line.”
Susan looked through the materials.
“You’ve owned the house less than a year.”
Martin nodded.
“Yes.”
“And the prior owners submitted a written statement confirming they recognized the surveyed line.”
Another nod.
“Yes.”
“And your client’s own permit application appears to show essentially the same boundary.”
Silence.
Susan turned to Tyler.
“Is there another survey?”
Tyler looked at Martin.
Martin answered:
“Not one we intend to rely upon today.”
That was attorney language for no.
Susan continued.
“Then what exactly are we mediating?”
Tyler finally spoke.
“The cost.”
“What cost?”
“Moving everything.”
Susan looked toward me.
“Mr. Miller, are you demanding removal of landscaping that does not physically encroach?”
“No.”
“Only improvements located on your parcel or necessary to restore access?”
“Yes.”
She nodded.
Then turned back to Tyler.
“That sounds narrower than it could be.”
He did not appreciate that.
For nearly three hours, we negotiated.
Eventually, a practical solution emerged.
Tyler would relocate the fence entirely onto his own property.
He would remove the portion of concrete pad crossing the line.
Any disturbed soil on my side would be restored.
A licensed contractor would perform the work.
Carl would return afterward to verify the boundary.
Tyler would cover the survey recheck and a portion of my attorney fees.
The Japanese maples could remain if they were relocated.
I did not care about punishing trees.
The hot tub became Tyler’s bigger problem.
With the fence moved to the true line, the pad no longer fit the backyard design the way he wanted.
He could relocate it.
Redesign it.
Or remove it.
That was between Tyler and the county.
I did not ask for more.
Then Tyler made one last attempt.
“What if Jason gives us a two-foot easement?”
I answered immediately.
“No.”
He glared.
“You won’t even consider it?”
“I considered giving you eight feet for thirty days.”
The mediator coughed into her hand.
Ashley looked down.
Rachel kicked my shoe lightly beneath the table.
Apparently that had been too satisfying.
Still, the agreement was signed.
Tyler had forty-five days.
For the first three weeks, nothing happened.
Then a contractor arrived.
The cedar boards came down one section at a time.
I stood in my kitchen watching.
Emma came downstairs.
“It’s happening?”
“Yes.”
She looked through the window.
“Can I wave?”
“No.”
“Can I smile?”
“Inside the house.”
She smiled magnificently.
The contractor removed the posts.
The artificial line disappeared.
Suddenly, the yard looked like mine again.
Not larger.
Mine.
Carl returned after the new posts were installed.
He measured everything.
Then handed me the verification.
“Four inches inside Bennett’s property.”
I blinked.
“Why four?”
Carl grinned.
“His contractor apparently wanted no future debate.”
Smart man.
The concrete removal took another day.
Workers cut away the portion extending onto my parcel.
Tyler had to redesign the edge of his patio.
The ornamental stone was moved.
The sod was repaired.
The drainage access remained clear.
When everything was finished, Rachel sent me the final settlement confirmation.
Case closed.
At least legally.
Neighbor relationships were another matter.
Tyler stopped speaking to me.
That was fine.
Ashley still waved occasionally.
Six months later, she knocked on my door again.
“We’re selling.”
I was surprised.
“Because of this?”
She hesitated.
“Not only this.”
I did not ask.
Some questions are invitations into somebody else’s marriage.
I had learned enough about boundaries for one year.
Their house sold two months later.
The buyers were a couple named David and Priya Shah.
On moving day, David walked over.
“Are you Jason?”
“Yes.”
He pointed toward the fence.
“The previous owner said there had been a boundary disagreement.”
“There was.”
“Resolved?”
“Yes.”
I showed him the latest survey markers.
He laughed.
See more on the next page
