He drove a very clean Range Rover.
He came to my house four days after I returned from the Bakken.
I watched him from the kitchen window as he parked.
He walked to the door with the gait of someone who has decided that the situation is manageable and who is deploying the particular confidence that this decision produces.
I opened the door before he knocked.
He said: Mr. Aldridge, I’m Dale Forsythe, president of the Glacier Crest HOA. I’m glad you’re back. We’ve been looking forward to having a conversation.
I said: come in.
He came in.
He sat at the kitchen table.
Linnea put coffee in front of him without being asked because that is what she does for guests, and then she went into the other room, which was also what she did because she knew I needed the room.
He said: I want to be upfront with you. We made an error in the surveying process and the cabin ended up a bit outside our intended boundary.
A bit outside.
I said: I have the 1962 survey here.
I put the binder on the table.
I opened it to the survey page.
I said: the cabin is approximately forty-two feet inside my boundary at its nearest point. The dock extends an additional sixty feet onto my land and into the creek arm, which I can demonstrate runs across my property in this section.
I did not raise my voice.
I said it the way I said most things, which was precisely and without unnecessary emotion.
He looked at the survey.
He said: we’re prepared to compensate you for the inconvenience.
I said: what figure did you have in mind?
He said: we were thinking around twelve thousand dollars. Given the circumstances.
I said: given the circumstances.
He said: we understand this has been disruptive.
I said: Dale.
He said: yes?
I said: you built a 2,400-square-foot cabin on my pasture while I was away on a job. You’ve been booking it at $1,400 a night since it was completed. It’s been booked solid through April.
He said: we understand there are some concerns.
I said: there are no permits for the structure. There are no permits for the dock. There are no permits for the septic system, which is currently venting on my property without my consent.
He said: those are administrative issues we’re working to resolve.
I said: they’re not administrative issues. They’re violations of state building codes, county ordinances, and several provisions of the Montana trespass statute.
He said: Holt.
He used my first name.
The specific move of a man who has decided that familiarity will produce warmth.
He said: I think we can work this out like reasonable people.
I said: I’m very reasonable, Dale.
I said: my lawyer is going to file for an emergency injunction to cease all rental activity on the property. He’s also going to file for a court order requiring removal of the structure at the HOA’s expense, plus damages for unauthorized use of the property since the cabin was completed.
He said: that seems like an aggressive approach.
I said: it’s the appropriate approach.
He said: what would a different approach look like?
I said: I don’t have a different approach in mind right now. My approach right now is the legal one.
He said: there must be a number that works for you.
I looked at him.
He was a man who believed that every problem had a price and that the price was the problem, that underneath every dispute was a calculation and that identifying the right number resolved the calculation.
He was not wrong about some disputes.
He was wrong about this one.
I said: Dale, my grandfather homesteaded this land in 1916. My father bought additional sections and commissioned a survey in 1962 that establishes exactly where my boundary runs. I bought out my siblings in 2002. The Aldridge family has held this land for a hundred and seven years.
I said: no number you write on a check is going to replace the hundred and seven years.
He said: I’m not asking you to give up the land. I’m asking you to allow the cabin to remain.
I said: no.
He said: we can write you in as a co-beneficiary of the rental income.
I said: no.
He said: we can extend your property into Glacier Crest territory in exchange. Give you an equivalent acreage.
I said: no.
He said: Holt, demolishing a $2.4 million structure is going to be a mess. For everyone.
I said: yes. It will be.
He said: the legal process will take years.
I said: it will take as long as it takes.
He said: we’ll make your life difficult.
He said it quietly, almost as a footnote, the sentence that arrives when the negotiation has moved past persuasion and into something else.
I looked at him.
I said: Dale, I’ve run heavy equipment in conditions that would make you weep. I’ve worked in weather that was genuinely dangerous. I’ve spent fifteen years on pipeline jobs in places where the ground didn’t want to be moved and the weather didn’t want me there. I’ve done all of that because it was the work that needed doing.
I said: you are not difficult.
He said nothing.
I said: I’d like you to leave now.
He stood up.
He looked at the binder.
He looked at me.
He left.
The injunction took three weeks.
Sutton moved it through the district court with the specific efficiency of someone who knew what he was looking at and had everything he needed.
The judge was a woman named Harriet Callan who had been sitting in Flathead County for fourteen years and who had the reputation for decisions that were meticulous rather than fast. She read the filings over a weekend, which Sutton told me was unusual, which I took as a sign.
The injunction was granted.
Rental activity was ordered to cease immediately.
The HOA was given sixty days to present evidence of valid permits, valid survey data establishing their right to the property, or a legal basis for the structure’s presence.
They presented none of these things.
What they presented, through their attorney, was a counter-offer.
The counter-offer was for $180,000.
Sutton called me when it came in.
He said: they’ve come up considerably.
I said: yes.
He said: it’s real money.
I said: yes.
He said: what do you want to do?
See more on the next page
