Several more appeared along roads outside town.

Near one mark, Eleanor had written:

J.J. Mill — Saturday, 9 a.m. Bring thank-you card.

My mind spiraled.

A meeting place.

A specific time.

A handwritten map.

Coded bags.

This was getting worse.

I took a picture and sent it to my sister, Margot.

Look what I found beneath my in-laws’ mattress.

Her response came almost immediately.

CLAIRE. WHAT IS THAT?

I don’t know.

Is that what I think it is???

I don’t know what to think.

Do you call the police? Do you NOT call the police? Oh my God.

Thomas is coming. We’ll figure it out.

Tell me the SECOND he gets there.

I put the phone down and sat on the mattress.

Sunlight still filled the room.

The curtain still moved gently in the breeze.

Everything looked peaceful.

And yet, in my mind, the entire family I knew had changed.

There was another reason I had panicked so quickly.

A reason Thomas knew about but rarely mentioned.

My mother.

When I was twelve, I discovered something hidden under my parents’ bed.

I had been looking for a missing shoe when my hand touched a shopping bag.

Inside were brand-new items with tags still attached.

Scarves.

Books.

Kitchenware.

Things our family could not afford.

Things my mother had never purchased.

That afternoon, I discovered she was a compulsive shoplifter.

For years, she had hidden stolen items around our home.

Closets.

Drawers.

The trunk of the car.

Under beds.

My father knew.

Eventually, I knew too.

And instead of getting proper help, we became a family organized around her secret.

I learned to watch her carefully in stores.

I learned the look she got when she was tempted.

I learned how to distract employees.

I learned how to remain silent.

At twelve years old, I learned one lesson that stayed with me far longer than it should have:

The people you love can hide entire lives behind closed doors.

Ever since then, secrecy made me nervous.

Closed doors made me nervous.

Anything unexplained immediately felt dangerous.

And now I was kneeling beside another bed, staring at another secret hidden by someone I loved.

“Not again,” I whispered.

Then Thomas appeared in the doorway.

“Claire, what did you—”

He stopped.

His eyes moved across the room.

The suitcase.

The bags.

The notebook.

The map.

Before either of us said another word, a car pulled into the driveway.

I hurried to the window.

Eleanor’s silver sedan.

Harold sat in the passenger seat adjusting his glasses like he was arriving for an ordinary Saturday visit.

I spun toward Thomas.

“What did you do?”

“I called them.”

“You WHAT?”

“I thought whatever you found probably belonged to them. I asked them to come pick it up.”

“You called them before you even looked at it?”

“I didn’t know it was this!”

The front door opened downstairs.

Eleanor’s cheerful voice floated toward us.

“Hello? It’s only us!”

Seconds later, she walked into the guest room carrying a container of banana bread.

“Sweetheart,” she said, “we were already planning to drop this off as a thank-you for letting us stay here, and then Thomas said you seemed upset about—”

She stopped.

Her eyes reached the floor.

For several seconds, nobody spoke.

Then Eleanor’s expression changed.

First confusion.

Then recognition.

Then embarrassment.

Her entire face turned pink.

She slowly sat down on the edge of the bed.

“Oh.”

I stared at her.

“Oh?”

She put one hand over her mouth.

“Claire… did you open any of them?”

“No.”

Her entire body relaxed.

“Oh, thank goodness.”

And then she laughed.

Actually laughed.

It was a strange, embarrassed little laugh, but under the circumstances it nearly pushed me over the edge.

“Eleanor!”

Her eyes filled with tears as she tried to stop laughing.

Harold stepped closer and placed a hand on her shoulder.

“Ellie,” he said gently, “just tell them.”

Thomas looked at his mother.

“Mom. Please. Whatever this is, you need to explain it.”

Eleanor twisted her wedding ring.

“I thought I packed everything yesterday,” she said. “The suitcase was too full, so I put the last few bags beneath the mattress. I intended to come back today, bring the banana bread, and take them home before anyone noticed.”

Thomas closed his eyes.

“Mom, that explanation is somehow making this worse.”

“I know.”

Harold coughed into his hand.

I could tell he was trying not to laugh.

I pointed at him.

“Do not laugh, Harold.”

“I’m not.”

“You absolutely are.”

That nearly made him lose control.

“Someone,” I said, “please tell me what is happening before I completely lose my mind.”

Harold looked lovingly at his wife.

“It’s not anything terrible,” he said. “Tell her, flour girl.”

Eleanor immediately gave him a wounded look.

Harold’s smile vanished.

“Sorry, Ellie.”

Something about that tiny interaction finally penetrated my panic.

Eleanor didn’t look like a woman terrified because she had been caught committing a crime.

She looked like a woman mortified because somebody had discovered an embarrassing hobby.

I crouched beside the nearest bag.

“Eleanor, I’m opening this.”

“Oh, Claire, you really don’t have to—”

“I absolutely do.”

The label said E-14.

My fingers trembled as I opened the zip seal.

I expected something chemical.

Harsh.

Unfamiliar.

Instead, almost nothing happened.

Then I smelled it again.

That faint, nutty, warm scent.

The smell I had noticed in the guest room for six months.

I brought the bag closer.

See more on the next page