My heart hammered.
“Rex?”
He didn’t answer.
“Were you Grace’s father?”
He shouldn’t have burdened you.
Silence.
Grace spoke quietly. “You’re looking at my father, Aunt Kendall.”
Rex covered his face. “I’m sorry.”
“Dad told me Rex had been seeing Mom in the months leading up to your wedding.”
I stared at my husband. “You were sleeping with Nancy?”
Her real father was already married.
“It was brief.”
“And she became pregnant?”
“Yes.”
“Before our wedding?”
Rex nodded. “But I didn’t find out until shortly afterward.”
You’re looking at my father.
“And you kept it from me for fifty years?”
“I was terrified you’d leave.”
I laughed bitterly. “So you asked Walter to solve your problem?”
“He’d just returned. Nancy needed someone. The baby needed a father.”
Grace interrupted. “And you needed somewhere to hide your daughter.”
I didn’t find out until shortly afterward.
Rex whispered, “That’s not fair.”
“Fair?” she repeated. “I called you Uncle Rex my entire life.”
Grace finally knew who her real father was.
But Rex still had one more secret to answer for.
You needed somewhere to hide your daughter.
“Walter refused at first,” Rex admitted. “I only asked him to help Nancy during her pregnancy. Groceries, doctor’s visits. If I’d done it, people would’ve gotten suspicious.”
“And then?”
“He fell in love with her. Decided to marry her himself.”
“And you both agreed to lie?”
“We agreed to keep it a secret.”
Rex still had one more secret to answer for.
“My God, Rex. You’re disgusting.”
She stared at him. “And you watched me grow up. Birthdays, Christmases, graduations. Did you ever feel guilty?”
“Every day.”
“Not enough to tell me.”
“Did Mom ever ask you to tell me?” Grace demanded.
We agreed to keep it a secret.
“Once. I convinced her it would destroy both families.”
“So you made her keep lying too?”
“I helped financially.”
“So you bought his silence?” I asked.
It would destroy both families.
“I was protecting everyone.”
“No,” Grace said. “Dad loved me enough to raise me. You couldn’t even admit I was yours.”
Rex lowered his head.
“I’m sorry.”
“Did Walter know about the hidden letters?”
I was protecting everyone.
“Yes.”
“Did he forgive you?”
“Never completely.”
Grace leaned forward. “Twenty years ago, Dad warned you he wouldn’t keep your secret forever.”
“I know,” Rex muttered.
You couldn’t even admit I was yours.
“Then why didn’t you tell us?” I demanded.
“Because I knew you’d leave me.”
“Why?”
“I’d already lied about Walter’s letters. And then there was Nancy.”
“So?”
He wouldn’t keep your secret forever.
“I saw how you and Walter looked at each other. If you left me, I knew you’d go straight to him.”
“And that’s why you stole my letters?”
“I couldn’t lose you.”
“But Grace? She’s your daughter, Rex!”
“I know.”
I knew you’d go straight to him.
“You let your brother raise her while you played the loving uncle. How could you?”
“I thought I was protecting everyone.”
“No. You were protecting yourself. For fifty years.”
Rex began crying. “Walter was her real father in every way that mattered.”
Grace shook her head. “He was my dad. He always will be. But his love doesn’t excuse your cowardice.”
She’s your daughter, Rex!
I looked at Rex. “Did you marry me because you loved me, or because you knew I wouldn’t discover your secrets?”
He opened his mouth.
Nothing came out.
Rex had spent fifty years deciding what I deserved to know.
Now it was my turn to decide.
His love doesn’t excuse your cowardice.
“I betrayed you three times,” I said. “I’m responsible for that.”
“Then surely you understand…”
“Understanding isn’t excusing. You stole my letters and decided which truths I deserved.”
“I gave you a wonderful life.”
“We built that life, Rex. But you manipulated its beginning.”
It was my turn to decide.
“Our children…”
“Deserve honesty.”
“Then stay.”
“I can’t.”
Grace squeezed my hand. “I’m sorry, Aunt Kendall.”
You manipulated its beginning.
“You have nothing to apologize for.”
Rex looked at me. “What happens now?”
“I’m moving out. I’m seventy-two. I won’t waste another year pretending I never found those letters.”
***
Two weeks later, I rented a cottage beside a lake.
Emily helped move my photography equipment.
Deserve honesty.
“Michael and Sophie are still processing everything,” she said.
“And you?”
“I’m angry at Dad. But I’m glad you told us.”
“I should’ve done it sooner.”
“Maybe. At least we’re done with secrets.”
I’m moving out.
“I hope so. I’ve had enough surprises for one lifetime.”
She set down my camera bag. “Mom, are you really starting again?”
“I never stopped being a photographer.”
“Then photograph something beautiful.”
I did.
At least we’re done with secrets.
***
Over the following weeks, I filled my days with photography.
I missed Rex sometimes, but I was learning to enjoy my own company.
One afternoon, he visited.
“I know I destroyed your trust,” he said. “Can we start over?”
“I don’t know, Rex. But we can talk.”
Photograph something beautiful.
“Will you come home?”
“Not yet. I’m happy here.”
He nodded, and we agreed to dinner.
For fifty years, I’d photographed our family’s happiest moments, never questioning what lay outside the frame.
See more on the next page
